Premier Story hit its stride the final
week of September.
The trial of O.J. Simpson began with jury selection in
downtown Los Angeles on a Friday, September 23, 1994. Tall scaffolding was erected
and trailers set up in a huge media encampment in the parking lot of the Hall
of Records across the street. Vendors were in place with their "Don't Squeeze
the Juice" buttons and "Free O.J." baseball caps. Protesters
had their placards. Tourists had their cameras. Police had their hands full.
Premier Story had a new idea. We were going to do the show
from outside the courthouse. Alison would get to prove just how good she was
on her feet, on the run.
We spent some money on this one, including three camera
crews. One we placed on a tenth-floor balcony across the way. Two roved around
to catch attorneys, key players and other activity on the short, tree-lined
street.
Most of the network reporters and anchormen divided their
time between a media room upstairs, where no cameras were allowed, and the scaffolded
encampment around the corner and across the street that was dubbed "Camp
O.J."
This was typical hands-off network television, another
Brandenburg Gate where the Brokaws and Gumbels and Rathers could stand in front
of their cameras with a nice tableau of the action behind them, while actually
being far and safe from it.
The grunts, the cameramen, lowly general assignment reporters
and producers, stationed themselves in "The Pit," at the foot of the
stairs that led from the sidewalk to the metal detectors at the courthouse door.
The Pit was where we set up a director's chair and microphone for Alison to
open the show and provide commentary as the melee raged behind her.
We were in place. Julie and Rio and Beth and the other
Premier Story kids had our coffees and pads and tapes. Hi-8 Joe roamed the parking
lot looking for faces he'd become familiar with in transcribing all the Simpson
footage.
There was a commotion up around the corner. Born-again
attorney Robert Kardashian was arriving, performing his real function-- bringing
a fresh suit for his pal O.J. to wear in court. Alison jumped up and told one
of the crews to follow.
I turned to Brennan. "Uh, should we get her to come
back?"
He smiled and shook his head. "I don't think we'd
be able to stop her."
Alison dived into the roiling crowd toward Kardashian,
the only woman amid the beefy cameramen and mike-holders. A couple of people
on the edge of the crowd were already shouting, "Where's the bag?"
She pushed her way through. "Mr. Kardashian, hello.
I'm Alison Holloway, good morning, Mr. Kardashian. I've been asking you for
some time--" The cameraman moving at her right had had enough of her pushing
him out of the way. He responded by swinging his heavy Beta camera and clocking
her in the head with the fifteen-pound battery. There was an audible knock,
like a hammer against wood, but Alison didn't skip a beat. "--where the
bag is? Will you tell me now, Mr. Kardashian?"
They were at the bottom of the pit. Kardashian mumbled
a few words but walked inside without giving up anything.
Alison sidestepped the crowd and beckoned the cameraman
closer. "Well, you know, I was saying earlier how dangerous it can be to
be in the middle of that sort of frenzy, when these people arrive and you try
to get some sort of quote, you try to talk to them and you try to get in there--
I hadn't done that before," she confided to the camera. "And I've
come off, I think, worse for wear. Let me just-- oww!"
Alison leaned into the lens and pulled back her bangs to
reveal a lump the size of a Grade A jumbo egg directly over her right brow.
She smiled and kept on talking. "One of the cameramen hit me with the back
of his camera. I actually think he knew he was doing it, cause he said to me,
'Get out the way,' and I wasn't going to get out the way and this is the result."
She looked into the camera as if it were a mirror and mussed
her bangs to cover the wound. "Oh, well, I'll just pull my hair over it.
I hope it's okay."
She shrugged and walked off camera. Cut.
Brennan and I stood stunned and amazed. She was sensational.
We had our promo. We had our show. We had our new direction.
"Somebody get her some ice."
With Premier Story's new persona, tabloid TV had taken over
the news. Nobody was doing television like this and word about Holloway's performance
spread over the weekend. With a camera crew and a microphone and a small troupe
of producers with Hi-8 cameras and notepads, Premier Story managed to bring
the viewer into the middle of the chaos and make some sense of it.
The shows became a commentary on the media as well as the
justice system; unlike the ponderous pundits who look down from a place safely
removed from the scene, we were reveling in the thick of it, getting people
and places the "big boys" wouldn't even notice.
There was John Roberts, Dan Rather's heir apparent at CBS,
sitting with his little laptop outside a trailer in Camp O.J., complaining,
"The problem with this story is there's a dearth of pictures"--while
four-story scaffolding loomed over his head and a circus performed around him.
There was the now-deceased rapper, Tupac Shakur, at court to face another weapons
charge, recognizing Alison and expressing concern about her head wound.
There was the reporter from a city in the Midwest, so excited
to be covering such a big story. "We're in a trailer with about seven ABC
affiliates from around the country and we're all great friends now. None of
us knew each other before," he said, as if Camp O.J. were actually some
sort of Camp Runamuck. "We're all cooperating, swapping tapes: 'Did you
get this? Who got Shapiro today? Did anybody get O.J. at the jail?' All switching
and swapping and you don't usually see that in the media."
"No, of course not," Alison said, smart enough
to just let him talk.
"That's very unusual."
"So where's the sense of rivalry now? Has it gone
completely?"
"I think we put it aside for now, because I think
we've all realized that very few of us are ever gonna get an exclusive with
this and the best thing to do is be cooperative and please the bosses back home."
Perhaps we were revealing too much about the media.
We were making our way back from shooting at Camp O.J. when
we noticed someone had taken over our spot in the pit.
I nudged Brennan. "Holy mack'rel, will you look who
it is."
"Oh, yes, oh, yes," he said, and took Alison
by the arm and pointed out the person we were talking about. Alison laughed
and told Jay Kay the cameraman what she'd do next. He rolled, she gave a wink,
and talked to her friend the camera.
"Something interesting has happened this morning.
I came to the courthouse steps to take up my usual position down there at the
base of the steps--and someone was standing in our spot. Jeff Greenfield, reporter
for Nightline. They've finally decided to come down. They must have thought
it's a good idea."
It was beyond great. Nightline was chasing us again, deigning
to cover a story that Premier Story had run away with the past two nights. What
was even better: Greenfield was in our space, and he looked like a boob, standing
on a small stepladder looking down at the mass of media and clucking his tongue
in disapproval, while a man in sports jacket and dark glasses held Greenfield's
luggage--and the ladder, so his star wouldn't tumble.
We couldn't ask for a broader target; now Alison was on
her way with a big smile on her face to shake Jeff Greenfield's hand and ask
him a few questions. This was Gordon Elliott shouting through a bullhorn at
Bryant Gumbel's boat; Hard Copy pouncing on Maury Povich down the street from
the Fox building.
If anyone would see the humor, it would be the wiseacre
"new journalism" pioneer Jeff Greenfield, who came all the way from
New York to do a critical commentary on the media's O.J. obsession.
Alison was making her way through the crowd as Greenfield
stepped gingerly off the ladder. "There he is now," she informed the
camera. "Blue shirt; having a chat to his producer. Let's go in. Let's
go have a word." Greenfield noticed the woman and camera heading his way.
"Jeff. I'm Alison Holloway from Premier Story."
He backed off as if confronted by a bad smell. "I
know, but--"
"Can I shake you by the hand? I very much enjoy your
program and I saw you down here for the first time today. What made you come
down today?"
Greenfield hemmed. "No, no." Then he hawed. "I
don't want to talk about that; it's not appropriate for me--"
"Really?"
"Yeah, it really isn't."
Around them, producers from other networks and stations
were nudging cameramen. Cameramen were hoisting their gear and shooting the
confrontation between the upstart late night show and the mighty Nightline--which
had apparently pulled rank and muscled into Premier Story's battle-won spot
by the door.
Alison carried on with a smile; taking the piss, as they'd
say. "I just thought it would be fun to have a very brief chat--"
Greenfield looked embarrassed, yet patronizing. "No,
the last thing--"
"No, I understand you're tied up. We're all very busy
down here. I just think-"
"I know. No, but I appreciate it and thanks for the
kind words. But I'd just as soon--"
"Okay. Well, nice to see you. And see you around for
the duration of the trial-"
"Oh, no." Greenfield laughed at her. Was she
kidding? Lower himself like that? "No."
"We're here for the long haul," Alison said.
"I'm sure we will."
Other journalists laughed at the confrontation. As Greenfield
muttered something to his producer-bag holder, the thought of him laughing at
us like that really rankled.
I whispered to Joe: "Go over and ask him what he thinks
of Premier Story. Ask him why he wouldn't talk to Alison. Ask him what he's
scared of."
Joe ambled over with his Hi-8. "Excuse me. Why wouldn't
you speak to Alison Holloway?"
Greenfield gulped and turned away from the camera. "No."
"Who are you with?" Joe had been asking many
journalists which organizations they represented. Edited together, it would
make an impressive end-of-show montage. Greenfield felt himself to be a man
who needed no introduction.
"Why wouldn't you speak to Alison?"
There were more hearty laughs from comrades waiting for
the next burst of activity. Jeff Greenfield, the man who for years pontificated
about the media, who in 1988 said news had been taken over by "electronic
barbarians; the carriers of the basest impulses unrestrained by shame, or for
that matter, pride," was seeing the camera turned back on him.
"What do you think of Premier Story?"
"Shall we just walk over there?" Greenfield suggested
to his producer-ladder holder. They snatched the bags and set off toward the
safety of Camp O.J. across the street.
Joe followed a few steps behind. "Why wouldn't you
speak with Alison Holloway? Why are you running away?"
Greenfield skittered away to derisive laughter from the
grunts in the pit. Our cameraman, Jay Kay, kept his distance as Joe followed
the pair across the street. Spectators, vendors, cops and journalists alike
looked on with a smile. Yeah, who's he to drop in from the airport to stand
on a ladder, survey the scene, have a glass of Perrier at Camp O.J., and then
fly back first class to file a report saying that all us people who care about
this case are idiots?
Jeff Greenfield, to paraphrase Tom Wolfe, his buddy from
Elaine's, was being mau-maued.
"What do you think of Premier Story?"
Greenfield and his manservant were safely across the road,
entering the guarded Camp O.J., seconds from shaking young Joe, when they were
assaulted from the front. A tall man in a permapress suit accompanied by a cameraman
stepped forward to welcome the star to the isle of civility. "You know,
usually you're the guy looking at the media," he crowed in a Southern-fried
anchorman's voice. "Today, the media looks at you too, right?"
Jeff Greenfield gave him a pained, "Are you an asshole?"
look.
"Richard Belcher with your ABC affiliate in Atlanta,"
the man said, extending a hand and sucking up to the big network boy at exactly
the wrong time.
"Hi," Greenfield mumbled, giving an ix-nay on
the alk-tay jerk of the head toward Joe that Belcher didn't notice. "How
you doin."
"Fine. You got time for six hundred questions we're
gonna ask you?"
This man from his Atlanta affiliate was worse than the
kid with the camera standing nearby. Greenfield muttered. "Yeah, um, but
I think we oughta just wait until this rather unpleasant young man is finished."
Joe laughed in good-natured surprise.
Belcher pressed on with forced joviality, trying to make
an impression on his bigtime colleague. "He's one of about twelve with
Premier Story. Have you met him?"
"No, but I, you know--"
"My name is Joe Guidry," Joe said, extending
his free hand. "How you doing?"
"No," said Greenfield. "I have no interest
in shaking your hand. This is the kind of lack of civility that I really think
is unfortunate." He turned to Belcher. "So we're not going to do anything
until he is...weary."
Belcher looked at Joe. "Can I have a second with him?"
"No problem," Joe replied.
"Can I?"
Greenfield sighed. "No, I'm--"
"I'm just asking him," Belcher said a little
too sharply to Greenfield. He had no idea what his idol had been through. "See,
I've cut my separate deal with him."
Joe realized he was being treated like some kind of gang
member. "I just wanted to ask him who he was with," he said.
Greenfield shook his head. "Well, we're not gonna
get into--"
Belcher stepped in it again. "Jeff Greenfield, with
ABC News," he said confidentially.
"ABC News? Okay."
Greenfield rolled his eyes. "See, that's just what--"
He sighed, defeated.
Belcher pressed on with his interview. "But look,
you've made, for years-"
Greenfield turned his back to Joe's camera and shook his
head. He wasn't going to answer any questions.
"I'm not interviewing you," Belcher said. He
was getting fed up. It was clear that Greenfield had gone from journalistic
hero to pompous poop before his very eyes. "But this is part of what you
do expertly, is to observe this kind of stuff. Is this the first time you've
seen one like this?"
Greenfield shook his head again, and for the first time
his bag handler spoke.
"He's still shooting!" Snitch. Rat fink!
The good old boy was getting fed up. "I'm not. I'm
not."
"He is." Greenfield winced as if he was having
a particularly unpleasant attack of intestinal gas. There was an uncomfortable
silence.
Joe broke it. "Who was that guy who was holding your
ladder? Is it like, do you just hire him as a ladder holder?"
That did it. Greenfield turned to the camera and stuck
his damp face close to Joe's lens. "You don't get it, do you?"
"I'm just asking a question."
"No. This is in-civil. It's rude. It's invasive. And
it's part of the problem. And you are part of the problem, not the solution."
Greenfield was winding up into his best journalism schoolmarm lecture. "This
is not the way to do journalism. And I feel very sorry for you if you have any
hope for a career in it.
"This is unpleasant business." He picked up his
bags. "Okay?"
Joe stayed put as the Nightline commentator, valet in tow,
harrumphed off behind the Camp O.J. scaffolding.
"Thank you," Joe said and, after a moment, added,
"Are you hiring?"
The Greenfield segment was the talk of the courthouse
the next morning. We'd gotten an item into Page Six of the New York Post that
made it seem old Jeff was a spoilsport putting the whammy on Joe Guidry's chance
at a career. The phones and fax lines at Premier Story were ringing with calls
from newsrooms back in New York--ABC included--congratulating us for taking
the piss out of a holier-than-thou media commentator and showing him to be too
prickly and ungracious to share a word or two with the woman whose show was
beating the pants off Nightline on the Simpson story.
Not everyone was laughing. Alison was having a coffee in
The Pit when someone came over and warned her. Nightline was striking back.
They were going to be looking at the media, all right. They were focusing on
Premier Story.
We went about our business. Alison was interviewing a sidewalk
musician who'd been detained by police after following Johnny Cochran into the
courthouse, when I got a nudge from someone else-- an ABC cameraman was a few
feet away, shooting Alison.
I went up behind her and whispered in her ear. Alison turned
around and told Jay Kay to follow. "Hi," she said to the ABC cameraman.
"Why are you shooting me?"
The ABC veteran laughed, then sidestepped the question
and Alison as he did a humorous dance around his camera and tripod. It was all
good fun on the sidewalk--until a sharp voice cut through all the others.
"You're interviewing my cameraman?"
It was another of those bizarre, fortuitous television
moments. Until then, Alison had been the only woman on a sidewalk crowded with
sweaty male journalists, photographers, and street people. Suddenly there was
another female. She was blond, too, and her haircut was quite similar to Alison's.
Only she was about twenty years older and tough as a leftover Thanksgiving turkey.
"Hello, I'm Alison Holloway from Premier Story,"
Alison said.
"Judy Muller." She was another reporter from
Nightline, taking over from Jeff Greenfield, who was probably in bed with an
icebag on his head. She looked at Alison as if she were performing some unnatural
act, talking to the cameraman--the cameraman Judy Muller told to shoot Alison.
"Why are you interviewing my cameraman?
"Everybody is interviewing everybody else. Why are
you interviewing me?"
The crowd pushed closer, eager for a fight. Our second
cameraman, Chris Telford, moved in as well. Hi-8 Joe crouched and shot up from
the sidewalk. Judy Muller's cameraman zoomed in as well. The exchange that followed
was something out of Beckett.
"I'm trying to find out why you're interviewing us."
"Because it's sort of the media show, isn't it? Everybody's
interviewing everybody else. Do you think it's a good idea?"
"Lemme ask you a question, Alison," Judy Muller
said, her eyes in a mean squint and the lines on her face growing taut, "when
you yell questions at Kardashian like, 'What's in the bag' and 'Where is the
bag,' clearly you don't expect an answer like, 'My God, you've broken the case,
let me tell you right now, here on the sidewalk.' That's part of your shtick,
correct?"
Alison seemed taken aback. "Gosh, that's a very abrupt,
upfront and very direct question. Um, I wouldn't ask a question unless I expected
an answer. But you wouldn't ask me that question unless you expected an answer.
You know, we go round in circles."
"But you don't expect an answer when you, when you
ask that on the sidewalk?"
"Oh, I might, but I might not. I might, but I might
not. You know, it's a very important issue. Let's not get away from what we're
dealing with here. That's a very important issue. Let's not make light of it,
okay?"
"I don't make light of it. But don't we make light
of it when we conduct that sort of thing on the sidewalk?"
"Are you saying you wouldn't conduct that sort of
thing on the sidewalk?"
"That's what I'm saying, yeah." Judy Muller's
face was stretched back in a rictus grin. She looked like she wanted to kill.
"Are you?" Alison said. A print reporter scribbled
notes. Everyone else waited to see who would throw the first punch. "Oh."
"No?"
"Oh, you're holier than thou," Alison said. "No,
I don't think so."
"Okay, thanks."
With that, they backed off. Judy Muller turned and slipped
into the crowd.
I turned and smiled. "Hey, Joe!"
Judy Muller corraled her cameraman and producer and was rushing
toward the safety of Camp O.J. Waiting for the traffic to pass, she noticed
the young black man with the Hi-8 camera behind her.
Joe tried to get a question out. "Do you think--"
"Do me a favor," Judy Muller growled.
"Yes, ma'am," said Joe, following. "I just
want to ask you a question, just a couple of questions."
"I don't want to answer any. Bye!"
They were across the street. "No questions? None at
all?"
"Nope!" Judy Muller pretended to be hard at work.
She had the cameraman set up his tripod and shoot the CNN correspondent doing
a standup on a plywood stage.
"Don't you want to know what's inside of that bag?"
Joe asked. "Don't you want to know what's inside of that bag, ma'am?"
"Go away, fella." She pointed out something to
her producer.
"Please?" Joe was unfailingly polite. "Wouldn't
you like to know what's inside of the bag?"
Judy Muller put a hand to her lips and put her face into
the camera like Jeff Greenfield did. "Shhhhh! We are recording," she
whispered.
"Excuse me." Joe stood silent, the camera fixed
on the woman's hawklike profile. After a long pause came an almost inaudible
whisper from Joe. "Don't you want to know what's inside of the bag? Don't
you want to know what's inside of the bag?"
Judy Muller turned her head slightly to the camera and
said from the corner of her mouth, "Fuck off, fella."
Joe was stunned. He giggled like a little kid who'd just
heard a bad word. "Oh, you don't have to use profanity, now."
Judy Muller and her crew moved on. "Thank you very
much, ma'am," Joe said, meaning it. "Thank you. Tell Jeff I said hi!"
Fuck off fella! We had our promo for that night's show. Sure,
we put a bleep over most of the "fuck," but you sure got the message.
It was the highlight of our story about how the folks at
Nightline focused their cameras on us because of the Jeff Greenfield incident.
We re-ran highlights from that segment, followed by Alison's encounter with
the cameraman and the entire Judy Muller showdown, unedited, bouncing among
three cameras and climaxing with Hi-8 Joe and the immortal, "Fuh-bleep-cough,
fella."
I had to feel sorry for Judy Muller. She couldn't report
what it was really like in front of the courthouse. Her segment was rush-released
to Peter Jennings' World News Tonight broadcast, a two-minute, well-balanced
report on the "media circus" that described Alison as "one reporter
who uses the shtick of asking Robert Kardashian what he did with O.J. Simpson's
garment bag," followed by Alison's soundbite: "It's sort of the media
show, isn't it? Everybody's interviewing everybody else."
Fuck off, fella.
The mainstream media was not about to let us off the hook
so easily. Just as Peter Brennan waited for the other news shows to go after
Robert Kardashian once we exposed the bag story, so ABC News gave us our comeuppance
through other channels.
Both were in the print media.
The first was from Jeff Greenfield himself in his nationally-syndicated
newspaper column...
You might guess who fired the next shot across our bow:
Howard Rosenberg, using his column in the L.A. Times.
We didn't need to seek revenge. A few weeks later, Ted
Koppel and Nightline provided it for us.
When I heard about the Nightline segment, I had the tape
brought into the office and watched it with Brennan. We couldn't believe our
eyes. What a fool!
We set aside a minute or so at the end of that night's
show for a package making use of the clip. Alison set it up in the intro by
mentioning that our Hi-8 Joe discovered there were imitators out there. We dissolve
to Jeff Greenfield's infamous invocation: "This is not the way to do journalism."
Freeze on his face. Joe begins the track: "Boy, was
I disappointed. I finally got to meet one of my journalistic heroes, Jeff Greenfield,
at the O.J. Simpson trial, and he tells me that."
"This is unpleasant business," Greenfield adds.
"I know it's unpleasant, but I still wanted to get
into TV," Joe continues. "So, in order to facilitate our special access
to parts of America normally not open to a television news crew, I proposed
that I would go into these areas alone with a Hi-8 camera.
"And I got exclusives with people like Prince Charles--and
Kato! But I couldn't forget the hurtful words from Jeff Greenfield of Nightline."
Greenfield: "This is not the way to do journalism."
Joe: "So get this. This week, I accidentally turned
on Nightline--sorry, Alison--and there was Ted Koppel himself, doing a story
in prison. And guess how he shot it?"
Here we see Ted Koppel from the previous night's Nightline.
Ted is wearing a neat denim shirt, and he holds a Hi-8 camera as he is led by
guards into a cage with another man.
"In order to facilitate our special access to parts
of the prison normally not open to a television news crew," Ted intones
in voiceover, "we proposed that I would go into these areas alone with
a Hi-8 camera..."
There's Ted, looking like Charlie Brown in his safari outfit,
holding the biggest goddamn Hi-8 camera you could think of, with a huge shotgun
mike sticking off the front and all of it attached to headphones sitting like
earmuffs on his Alfred E. Neumann coiff.
They cut to Ted's POV of a prisoner. Ted asks, with squeaky
insouciance: "So, you're in maximum lockup, right?"
Dissolve from the con to Hi-8 Joe. "This is not the
way to do journalism," he just manages to get out, cracking up.
"But it works," Alison adds with a smile and
wink. "Doesn't it, Ted?"